1. Irrelevant

    I think I would assume the worst rather than the best when it comes to halflings. If they pick up a sword meant for a 6 foot something barbarian I can’t see them finding it overly heavy making it do anymore damage than it does when swung by that barbarian, I’d just see them being worse at swinging it.

  2. Andrew

    Yet another argument for playing Pathfinder where oversized weapons are easy.

    • Bartholomew Klick

      Love me some pathfinder. 🙂

  3. LoCkfin

    Okay, I get that most of this is homebrew anyway and you can do what you want in your game. That said, that’s not how Lucky and Disadvantage actually work. Disadvantage is resolved before you ever have a chance to use a point of luck, meaning that the only die left for the roll is the lower of the two you rolled with disadvantage. You may then use Lucky to roll another die and choose between those two, but the original high roll that was discarded is inaccessible to you.

    Not to be a downer, but everyone on the web seems to have collectively misunderstood how these two rules interact RAW. Lucky is good, but it’s this misunderstanding of how it interacts with disadvantage that makes it insanely broken.

    • Bartholomew Klick

      The devs have clarified that Lucky works the way described in this comic and that this is intended. You’re certainly free to rule otherwise at your table, but when we make stuff like this, we have to use the rules as they exist, not as they should exist.

Submit a Comment

Oversized weapons in Dungeons and Dragons 5e

Starfall, Page 9


Opportunity Attacks revisited

Opportunity attacks in 5e, in my humble opinion, make combat boring. Disengaging to avoid an Attack of Opportunity (AoO) sacrifices your own action but leaves the enemy’s in-tact, making it one of the worst trades in the game. While the mechanic can create tense...

Starfall Part 2, Page 7

Super Quick Combat Rules

Quick preamble: this is probably system agnostic on some level, but I designed it for 5e. 5e’s design assumes you’re having probably way, way more combat encounters than you actually are, and that you’re playing long enough and quickly enough to resolve those...

Free VTT Tokens

I have created a repository of about 1200 VTT tokens that you guys can use for free. If you don't want to read more, you can just go to this link and grab them: https://www.patreon.com/posts/54992126 Why Tokens? I like them. During 2020, all of my D&D came to a...

Pathfinder 2e on Foundry vtt

I am a huge fan of Foundry VTT. For my purposes, it is the perfect virtual tabletop system. It supports a ton of systems, including the two that I love the best, namely Dungeons & Dragons 5e (DD5E) and Pathfinder 2e (PF2E). A massive part of the appeal of a VTT...

Starfall Part 2, Page 6

A One Shot

Hey guys, I am working on a major website overhaul, and then it'll be back into Starfall. In the meantime, have a golden oldie from the Patreon archive.

Better Know a Monster: The Mimic

I love the idea that mimics are cryptids to the rest of the world. Adventurers, at least with the players I've known, would be almost universally unpopular -- even when they save the world, they do it out of eyeshot of everyone else, and burn a lot of bridges to get...

The Hobgoblin (and you!)

It's been a hot minute since our last update because I've been dealing with a very sick pet rabbit, and it's leaving me absolutely drained. - This comic arose somewhat naturally out of my Red Hand of Doom group (retooled for 5e). Hobgoblins in 3.5 are just kind of...

The Trade – Page 5 (End)

To celebrate the release of Ricky's Guide to Spooptopia, we did a mini-arc about that setting's most infamous villain. We had fun making this, and it's based on, perhaps, the most dramatic character death I've ever had at a table. I always sub Candor and the gang out...

The Trade – Page 4

The Trade – Page 3

The Trade – Page 2

The Trade – Page 1


Starfall Part 2 – Murderlude

We cut quickly to Keelie, doin' her thing.

Get you that Fauci Ouchie

Seriously, y'all, I miss real dice. Get the vaccine. I got super lucky; I am on my first shot and get my second one in a few days. I'm working at the geological survey right now, and someone basically dropped from the rafters and jabbed my arm. (Well, it was more like...

Starfall Part 2 – Page 5

Hey everyone, We took a mental health day last week, but we're back. If you're enjoying Starfall, let us know. Feedback will help us decide what to make next. We should be reaching the end of this arc soon(ish).

oversized weapons

by | Jul 26, 2021 | Comics | 5 comments

Okay, so we did an info-graphic this week. We like the idea of building a 5e character around over-sized weapons, but the oversized weapons rules in this edition of D&D are helter-skelter at best.

This is not about game balance. At all. This is about throwing fistfuls of dice and splatting goblins. It’s also a little bit about showing some of the pain-points in the 5e ruleset when it comes to mechanically executing a fantasy idea. Oversized weapons get double damage dice per the DMG – but why not for halflings wielding medium weapons? Here, we navigate the inconsistent rules a bit to try to build the Buster Sword warrior of our dreams.

We couldn’t get everything in here. Rune knights and the Powerful Build feature can do a lot in a game where the DM allows over-sized weapons, but there’s already a ton of ‘mother-may-I’ in this build, and those felt niche.